Collection: Rentals - Play in Place!

Rental Collection

These are the games and mystery puzzles we have available for rent. 

For the current extraordinary situation, we are simplifying rentals to 7 day periods.

We are exploring the ability to reserve items as we understand that we are not as flexible as we might otherwise be - that is, we are shifting from you can rent what is on our shelves when you are in our Conundrum House, to we are listing what we have, and you put what you want to rent into your cart.

But then, picking up those items is another thing - we offer curbside pickup most afternoons, or by appointment, or delivery most mornings. You might not have any plans to come into downtown for a day or two, for instance. but you do want to be able to rent the specific game or puzzle you have your heart set on - we understand! 

So please bear with us as we adjust our e-commerce platform to accommodate these new ways of handling rentals. If you can't make the system do or understand what you want, please call us and we'll sort it out with you.

158 products
  • Rental - 221B Baker Street Deluxe Edition
    Rental - 221B Baker Street Deluxe Edition - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - 3 Secrets Crime Time
    Card Game, 3 Secrets - Rental - 3 Secrets Crime Time - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - 30 Second Mysteries
    Rental - 30 Second Mysteries - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - Arkham Horror: 3rd Edition - Core Set
    Arkham Horror: 3rd Edition - Core Set - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - Arkham Horror: Under Dark Waves
    Rental, Board Game - Rental - Arkham Horror: Under Dark Waves - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - Arkham Noir: #2: Called Forth By Thunder
    Rental, Card Game - Rental - Arkham Noir: #2: Called Forth By Thunder - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - Baker’s Dozen
    Rental - Baker’s Dozen
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - Bang!: 4th Edition
    Board Game, Card Game - Rental - Bang!: 4th Edition - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - BePuzzled 1000: Last Chill and Testament
    Rental - BePuzzled 1000: Last Chill and Testament - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - BePuzzled 1000: Sonata for a Spy
    Rental - BePuzzled 1000: Sonata for a Spy - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - BePuzzled 1000: the Ghost of Winthrop
    Rental - BePuzzled 1000: the Ghost of Winthrop - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50
  • Rental - BePuzzled 1000: the Glenmore Haunting
    Rental - BePuzzled 1000: the Glenmore Haunting - Conundrum House
    Regular price
    $7.50
    Sale price
    $7.50